The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in Shelter Island, NY

The Best Sugar-Free Wedding Cake Bakeries in Shelter Island, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads?


6 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Shelter Island, NY

Sugar-free
Clear
Quick responder
MWDyes Sweets 

5.0

  • Starts at $525
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY

I have been baking for 10+ years, and been in business for 5 years. What started off as a hobby turned into my greatest passion. I love bringing others vision to life through cake, I love the looks on my customer faces when thier dream cake comes into the room, this is my passion and I live what I do. I am here to make sure your special day goes as planned, and I am just grateful to be apart of making your day special.

Awarded Best of Zola
I recently placed an order with MWDyes, and it was by far the best decision I ever made. Not only was the cake beautiful, it was delicious. The vanilla buttercream is my favorite! My guest wanted seconds and I ate left overs at 12 am the next day because it was that good ! Place your orders today, you won’t regret it !
Faith G., a year ago
TrendlineTrending
Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC 

5.0

  • Starts at $180
  • Serves Shelter Island, NY for additional fees

Little Treats and Cakes by Janna specializes in wedding cakes and specialty cakes for all occasions. Our commitment is to create an original piece of edible art, that it’s not only beautiful but also very delicious. We not only offer cakes but also a variety of treats for your event like custom cupcakes, sugar cookies, and a full dessert menu which is created to match the theme and design of your event for an unforgettable sweets table. We also offer guest edible favors. At Little Treats and Cakes by Janna we also offer gluten free, dairy free and vegan options if you have dietary restrictions.

Working with Janna at Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC was an absolute pleasure. Their communication style was clear, warm, and incredibly helpful throughout the entire planning process. The quality of their work was truly outstanding - the cake and donuts they created for our wedding were not only stunning to look at, but also delicious beyond our expectations. Janna was incredibly easy to work with, and working with her virtually was a dream. Her attention to detail and willingness to bring our vision to life was unparalleled. I will surely be reaching out to Janna again for any future events, as her cake and donuts were everything we asked for and more.
Allison D., 17 days ago

Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Shelter Island, NY

About wedding cakes & desserts in Shelter Island, NY

How much do wedding cakes usually cost in Shelter Island, NY?

Wedding cake packages start at $475 and run up to $500 per person in Shelter Island, NY.

Do bakers in Shelter Island, NY offer cakes for special diets?

They do! 27 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 19 offer Vegan options.6 offer Sugar-free options.

What are the most popular cake and dessert options in Shelter Island, NY?

The most popular wedding cake vendors in Shelter Island, NY are Avas Cakes LLC, Sweet Buckets and Little Treats and Cakes by Janna, LLC.

What other Shelter Island vendors will I need?

What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

What other wedding services are nearby?