The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Payson, AZ

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Payson, AZ

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


43 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Payson, AZ

Quick responder
Kendra's Country Bakery 

5.0

Payson, AZ

    Welcome to Kendra's Country Bakery where every cake is customized to suit your needs! My initial inspiration comes from my grandparents. Although I was young when they passed, I can still remember my grandfather's signature red buttercream rose hidden on every cake. In the beginning, while raising my family with my husband, I was so excited to get into the baking world and learn what it had to offer. I had been baking for years so I decided to do what I love and share it with others!

    From the start, Kendra's Country Bakery was extremely professional and knowledgeable about their craft. They made us feel at ease about creating our dream cake and made this process stress free from the very beginning! Not going to lie, this was our favorite part of wedding planning. We were pleasantly surprised with all of the flavors they offered, it was so hard to choose, because everything was AMAZING and so DELICIOUS! Plus they had an awesome variety of desserts they offer and EVERYTHING is made from scratch! When I say they blew us away with their talent, they went above and beyond to create a show stopping centerpiece for us and our guests can't stop talking about it! I would 10/10 recommend! You get what you pay for and then some! They were so sweet, provided us with several extras as a gift for booking as well. If you want to have a stunning centerpiece that not just looks gorgeous, but ALSO tastes great, I would hands down go with Kendra's Bakery! You won't be disappointed!
    Maureen L., 13 days ago
    Quick responder
    A. Cakes Bakery 

    5.0

    • Starts at $400
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    I grew up in Omaha, Nebraska surrounded by weddings and events. My family owns an event venue there still. I took a detour and played professional golf for a number of years before A. Cakes was born in 2021. It was only fitting that I come full circle and work back in the wedding industry where my heart truly lies. I am in love with the process of learning, practicing and executing new and fun techniques on my clients’ cakes. More than that, creating a cake for someone’s special day gives me the most warm feeling. It’s truly why I do what I do.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    A. Cakes Bakery was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. They were incredibly adaptable, communicative, and understanding throughout the entire process. The cakes and desserts they created for our special day were not only delicious, but also true works of art. We came from out of town and accidentally had the time for pickup confused with our original time zone, but they worked with us to make sure we could pick it up late. They also have delicious and adorable tasting boxes that helped us find the perfect flavor - we ended up going with a champagne cake and loved it!
    Rachel, a month ago
    GemHidden gem
    Goodies by Max 

    5.0

    • Starts at $120
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Goodies by Max is a registered cottage home-based bakery in Desert Ridge, Phoenix AZ, specializes in custom decorated sugar cookies and cookie classes for private or company events! We love creating a custom set for each and every one of our customers for their special day.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    What an amazing experience to work with Lioni. My boss dropped into my lap at the 11th hour that she needed (200) individually wrapped cookies in 3 days for a conference. I received a lot of company names from friends, and everyone was booked to do 200 cookies so last minute. I thought there is NO WAY, I can find someone to do this nearly impossible job. Thank G-d I found Goodies by Max through my local area's Facebook page. Her posts and photos of cookies she had created were beautiful. Hallelujah! Although she was busy, she said, "I am up for the challenge!" . She was amazing to work with. She even delivered the cookies a day early! And they were delicious. I won so many "cookie" points from my boss. I WOULD RECOMMEND HER IN A SECOND!
    Elisa C., a year ago
    GemHidden gem
    Piece of Cake 

    4.8

    • Starts at $400
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    We have an awesome job! Seriously. Being in the business of making wedding cakes is amazing. Not only do we get to do for a living what millions of people do for a hobby, but we are constantly meeting couples that are in the midst of the happiest time of their lives. So, we love what we do and other people love what we do. Are you picking up what I'm putting down? Yep, it's good to be POC. Even cooler is the fact that not only do our customers love what we do, but the very best wedding reception sites in the valley trust us enough to stake their reputations on our work by including our cakes in their all inclusive wedding packages.

    The cake tasting process was so fun and the staff made the stress of picking a cake go away during it. They were so kind and had everything ready to go. The cake was everything we asked for and invisoned. Everyone loved the taste and look. They worked with my venue to coordinate final numbers, drop off time, and final touches. We cannot recommend Piece of Cake enough for your wedding!
    Corin H., 3 months ago
    Quick responder
    Bomb Confections 

    5.0

    • Starts at $1
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Welcome to my world of delectable creations! I'm Sandi, the passionate artisan behind these unique flavor-infused confections. For years, l've been crafting these delectables as a labor of love for family and friends during the holiday season. Their enthusiastic responses, filled with remarks like "You should be selling these" and "Oh my gosh, you made these?" fueled my culinary curiosity.

    We had the best experience working with Sandi at Bomb Confections for our wedding! The chocolates were absolutely delicious and they arrived perfectly for our wedding. They were a big hit with everyone! Sandi is one of the kindest, most generous and hard working people we’ve had the opportunity to know. We highly recommend Bomb Confections for your wedding or next event! Or even if you just want to some delicious, high quality chocolates and treats!
    Dara Z., 5 months ago
    Quick responder
    Artful Sweets 

    5.0

    • Starts at $450
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Artful Sweets, designs cakes and desserts that are all about you - your personal style, your ideas, your favorite flavors, your wedding dreams. So whether your dream cake is traditional or trendy, all white or colorful, round or geometric, romantic or whimsical, Artful Sweets will expertly design and deliver dazzling designs that taste as amazing as they look.

    We absolutely loved our cake. Susan was so thoughtful in listening to what we imagined it would look like and created a cake that was straight out of our dreams. And the flavors were so delicious! If you’re looking for a friendly baker to make your cake dreams come true, look no further!
    Abbey W., 7 months ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Ashley's Cakeshop 

    5.0

    • Starts at $96
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Ashley's Cakeshop offers wedding cake services in Phoenix, AZ. Owner Ashley Cuellar goes above and beyond to create a delicious and beautiful cake for your special day. She can design cakes in various themes and styles, so you know you are getting something that perfectly fits your unique vision. Ashley would be honored to add an extra element of sweetness to your magical day. Before the big day, she can organize a tasting session so you can choose the perfect cake for you. She can also take care of delivery and setup, so all you have to worry about is spending quality time with the people you love.

    I found Ashley’s cake shop on instagram and fell in love with her designs. I messaged her and let her know what things my sister would like for her cake (it was a surprise 30th birthday cake.) Ashley executed it beautifully! I am from Boston so visiting Arizona and having someone who was very responsive and helpful throughout the order/pickup process made our trip much better! Not to mention when we picked up the cake she went the extra mile and asked if we needed water because of how hot it was outside. Nonetheless Ashley is amazing, order your next cake from her you won’t regret it !
    Tayia, 17 days ago
    Quick responder
    Summer Sweets Bakery 

    5.0

    • Starts at $1,000
    • Serves Payson, AZ
    • Offer

    I was born and raised in a small town in the Philippines. I lived in California for 14 years and before moving to Arizona, I met my husband and my children (our lovely dogs). I started baking as far back as a little girl, with a simple interest in creating tasty treats for my family and I. Then I moved on to baking from scratch and began to appreciate the joy in producing and assembling each piece of the puzzle. Baking from scratch allows you to select not only the highest quality ingredients but it also creates a deeper connection between the baker and the food. As often happens, interest turned into a hobby, hobby turned into an obsession.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We highly recommend Julien for all of your baking needs. Her quality is unmatched and she is so great to work with. We've gotten multiple orders through her for our clients. She's able to replicate almost everything we envision. We highly recommend Summer Sweets Bakery!
    AJ with Picnic Point AZ, 3 years ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Sweet Buckets 

    5.0

    • Starts at $300
    • Serves Payson, AZ for additional fees

    We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
    Lyndsey C., 6 months ago
    GemHidden gem
    PrettyPiped 

    5.0

    • Starts at $168
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Hey! My name is Kailey Aird. I am the owner of PrettyPiped. First off, thank you so much for taking the time to look at my page! I wanted to tell you a little bit about me and my baking journey. My love for baking all started when I was around 8 years old. I would always ask my grandma to help her bake and idolized the work she did. I have always been a very artsy person, and once I found out that you can express your art onto an edible canvas I was sold! I jumped right into getting my licenses to bake from home and immediately started taking orders. Thanks again for taking the time to read this, and hopefully I have you as my next customer!

    I HIGHLY recommend PrettyPiped! I have loved (in taste and aesthetic) PrettyPiped cookies for about a year and she is my first go-to for custom cookies. They taste incredible and look amazing. I pitched an idea for my business anniversary celebration and she delivered. Hands down my favorite.
    Madeline, 3 years ago
    TrendlineTrending
    The Sultry Confectioner 

    5.0

    • Starts at $144
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    My name is Jennifer Keys and I am owner of The Sultry Confectioner. I have over 10 years experience in business. I specialize in custom cake designs for any occasion. My goal is to service your needs as best as I possibly can and make sure my services takes away the stress of finding the perfect cake artist for your special occasion.

    Working with this company was by far the greatest experience from placing my order to working out details for my cake to her putting her input in as far as direction with everything not only was my cake delivered one time not only was it beautiful and exactly what I vision it was so delicious. For our last tear at the bottom we were going to go with a dummy tear but she suggested to do a real tear and I’m so happy we went with her suggestion our whole entire cake was gone within minutes everyone loved how moist and delicious it was we got the butter pecan cake and it was amazing my husband has been so impatient with waiting for our year mark to defrost our topper it’s been crazy fighting him off I might have to order another cake because he won’t last until February lol. Thank you so much and we will definitely be back for more cakes!
    Latoya J., 2 years ago

    Location flexible? Discover cakes & desserts near Payson, AZ

    About wedding cakes & desserts in Payson, AZ

    How much do wedding cakes usually cost in Payson, AZ?

    Wedding cake package prices vary.

    Do bakers in Payson, AZ offer cakes for special diets?

    They do! 24 offer Gluten-free desserts, and 19 offer Vegan options.7 offer Sugar-free options.

    What are the most popular cake and dessert options in Payson, AZ?

    The most popular wedding cake vendors in Payson, AZ are Creative Ice Cream Events, BakerBitesCo and Sweet Buckets.

    What other Payson vendors will I need?

    What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

    What other wedding services are nearby?